Peyton Tully’s Multi-Sport Journey From Toledo to the NCAA
A story of perseverance, overcoming obstacles, and turning challenges into successes.
Women’s hockey is full of stories about grit, talent, and passion. Peyton Tully’s journey is one of them. From Toledo, Ohio, she’s made her mark both on the ice and the lacrosse field. This post looks at how she went from playing multiple sports growing up to becoming a standout NCAA athlete, highlighting her achievements and what she learned along the way.
Early Beginnings in Hockey
Peyton Tully’s journey into the world of hockey began in Toledo, Ohio, a place not typically recognized as a hockey hub. Growing up in a family with deep ties to the sport, Peyton was surrounded by hockey influences: her father played juniors, her mother was a figure skater, and her uncle even played professionally for the Toledo Storm, now known as the Toledo Walleye. It was during this formative time that Peyton developed a love for skating, often seen gliding across the ice from a young age. At just nine years old, asked her dad if she could start playing hockey, and, despite starting later than most, Peyton’s enthusiasm for the game was undeniable.
The Multi-Sport Athlete
While hockey captured her heart, Peyton was no stranger to other sports. She was active in everything from soccer to gymnastics, but it was her introduction to lacrosse in middle school that truly showcased her athletic versatility. As she juggled multiple sports, Peyton learned to balance her time effectively, a skill that would serve her well in high school and beyond. The hand-eye coordination and stick skills she developed in hockey translated seamlessly to her lacrosse game, illustrating the benefits of being a multi-sport athlete. Peyton believes that participating in various sports fosters overall athleticism, allowing athletes to return to their primary sport refreshed and with new skills.
Achievements and Recognition
Peyton’s hard work and dedication paid off when she earned accolades in her high school lacrosse career, including the prestigious Northern Lakes League Player of the Year award. Despite facing challenges, including an ACL injury that sidelined her during her freshman year, Peyton’s comeback was nothing short of remarkable. With her family by her side, her mother coaching her team, and her sister as a teammate, Peyton helped to lead her high school lacrosse team from an 0-16 record to an undefeated championship season. This experience solidified her identity as an athlete and ignited her desire to pursue collegiate sports.
Memorable Moments
Reflecting on her high school career, Peyton recalls a number of unforgettable moments that shaped her athletic journey. One standout memory was winning the league title in lacrosse during her senior year, a culmination of hard work and teamwork. On the hockey side, she remembers the experience of competing for state championships in Detroit, the emotional connections she formed with teammates and the lasting friendships made through the sport. These moments remind Peyton of the importance of community and the support system that sports create.
Conclusion
Peyton Tully’s journey is a testament to the power of determination, the value of versatility in sports, and the significance of family support. It’s about how someone can turn the struggles of a serious injury into an unexpected business opportunity that flexes creative muscles. Her story encourages young athletes to embrace challenges, explore multiple sports, and cherish the connections forged along the way. As Peyton embarks on her collegiate career at Post University, her experiences will undoubtedly inspire others to pursue their passions in sports and beyond.
Watch our full conversation on YouTube.


